How I decide whether a reverse mortgage fits: the questions I ask first.
Thirty years of files come down to a short list of questions. Here they are, in the order I ask them, with how I choose between programs and the situations where my advice is no.
The eight questions I ask first
In roughly this order. Most files are settled by the first four.
What is the money for?
A reverse mortgage is a tool, and a tool needs a job: ending a payment, covering a shortfall, a standby reserve, buying the next home. Ample savings and no concrete use means paying real costs for borrowing power you never touch, and I will say so.
How long will you live there?
Costs are paid up front. Over a stay of a few years they rarely earn their keep. If a move is likely, I show you what selling or a HELOC would cost instead.
Can you carry the taxes, insurance and upkeep?
The loan’s one hard rule. If those bills would strain the budget even with no mortgage payment, the loan has a problem from day one. I check that before I quote anything, and I put it in writing when it is a stretch.
Is there a mortgage, and is it worth keeping?
Paying off a lingering mortgage is the most common reason a reverse mortgage works: the payment disappears. A first mortgage at a rate well below today’s may be worth keeping, which points to a second-lien reverse.
Who is the youngest person on the title, and who else lives there?
Age drives the amount more than anything else. A spouse under 62, an adult child at home, or a partner not on title changes the structure, and sometimes the program.
Is the home above the federal limit?
The HECM counts a California home only up to $1,249,125. Above that, I price a jumbo reverse on the same day, from the same inputs, and show you both.
What do the documents say?
Trusts, condo approvals, HOA budgets, title. A condo file is decided by documents, not by the listing, and a home in a revocable living trust needs the trust read early. I read them before anyone hears a number.
Would a cheaper tool do the job?
A HELOC you can comfortably repay, a cash-out refinance, the State’s Property Tax Postponement, downsizing, or a family arrangement sometimes wins. I would rather lose the loan than sell the wrong one.
How I decide which program to price first
| If this is your situation | I price first | Why |
|---|---|---|
| You are 62 or older and the home is worth up to $1,249,125 | FHA HECM | Federally insured, non-recourse, a line of credit that grows |
| The home is worth more than $1,249,125 | HECM and jumbo, priced side by side | The jumbo counts the full appraised value; the HECM may still win on cost or on the growing line |
| You are 55 to 61 | Jumbo or second-lien reverse | The HECM is not available until 62 |
| You have a low-rate first mortgage worth keeping | Second-lien reverse or HELOC | Both leave the first mortgage in place; only the reverse has no payment |
| You are buying the next home | HECM for Purchase | No required monthly payment after the purchase |
| You will move within a few years | Usually not a reverse mortgage | Up-front costs need time to pay off |
I place proprietary programs from more than one wholesale lender, so the jumbo quote is a comparison, not a single offer. Every reverse program I place starts at 55.
When I tell someone not to get a reverse mortgage
A real list, from real files. When one of these applies I say no, and I show you the math.
A move is coming
Selling within a few years means the up-front costs never earn their keep.
The money has no job
Paying for borrowing power you will not use is a poor trade.
The obligations would pinch
If taxes, insurance and upkeep are already hard, the loan does not fix that.
The equity buys too little
When the balance would consume most of the home’s value without a matching benefit, the arithmetic fails.
Someone else needs the house
If a child plans to live there after you, the plan for repaying the loan has to come first, and sometimes the answer is a different tool.
A cheaper tool does the job
A HELOC you can repay, a refinance, the State’s tax postponement or downsizing.
The independent advice built into every file
A HUD-approved counselor
Required before any reverse mortgage, and independent of me and of every lender. California then gives you seven days before a final application can be taken or any fee charged (Cal. Civ. Code §1923.2).
Your attorney, when it matters
Trusts, divorce, conservatorship and estate plans belong with your attorney. I send trust documents to the lender for review on day one, and I never tell anyone to “just revoke the trust.”
Your planner or CPA
A reverse mortgage changes a retirement plan. I give your financial planner or CPA the same figures I give you, and the advisor page explains how planners use the loan.
Questions about how I work
How do you decide whether a reverse mortgage is right for someone?
Do you ever tell people not to get a reverse mortgage?
How do you choose between a HECM and a jumbo reverse mortgage?
The short version, both columns: reverse mortgage pros and cons.
The rest of the reverse mortgage library
Each page below covers one decision in full, rather than a paragraph of it. Start wherever your question is.
Want me to run the eight questions on your file?
Fifteen minutes on the phone. You will know which program fits, or why none does.
- The first call is free
- No application or documents needed for it
- I call you myself
- No obligation
Fifteen minutes. Real numbers. Then you decide.
Tell me the scenario and I’ll tell you honestly whether this is the right tool. If it isn’t, you’ll leave the call knowing why, and I’ll point you at whatever is.
(818) 674-7284Prefer email?
Send a couple of sentences about your situation and I’ll reply personally, usually the same business day.
Contact Ken Book a call