The California reverse mortgage appraisal and property eligibility guide.
Applies to: the FHA-insured HECM; private jumbo and second-lien programs where noted. Primary sources: 24 CFR 206.45, 24 CFR 206.47, HUD Mortgagee Letter 2022-11, HUD Mortgagee Letter 2025-08, HUD Mortgagee Letter 2017-18. Rules and pricing differ by lender and program, and your own figures depend on age, rate and value; not legal or tax advice. How I review.
Who orders the appraisal, how the value is reached, what happens when it is low, which homes qualify, and how repairs, solar leases and PACE liens are handled. Written from the HUD rules, with the numbers worked.
What the appraisal decides, and which homes qualify
A reverse mortgage is figured on what an appraiser says your home is worth, not on your estimate or a website’s. For the FHA-insured HECM the home must be where you live and be a single-family house, a two-to-four-unit building, an FHA-approvable condominium or a qualifying manufactured home. An appraiser from FHA’s roster sets the value and lists any repairs needed for safety, security and soundness. Repairs estimated at no more than 15% of the value the loan counts can be finished after closing from money set aside in the loan; larger repairs and real hazards come first. A value you think is low cannot be fixed by ordering another appraisal: the cures are better evidence, a smaller loan, or time.
- How a reverse mortgage appraisal works, step by step
- What happens when the appraisal comes in below your estimate
- Which property types qualify for a HECM
- Homes with a homeowners association: approval, dues and assessments
- Required repairs, the 15% rule and the repair set-aside
- Solar, PACE liens, unpermitted work and flood zones
- How the rules differ for a HECM, a jumbo and a second-lien reverse mortgage
- A low appraisal and a repair list, in dollars
- What is different about a California appraisal
- Where the general rules change
- What to do before the appraiser arrives
- The rules this guide is built on
- Related topics
How a reverse mortgage appraisal works, step by step
The appraisal does three jobs at once. It sets the value the loan is figured on. It decides whether the property is eligible at all. And it produces the repair list, if there is one. Here is the order things happen in.
- It is ordered after counseling and the seven-day waitFHA will not issue a case number until the lender has your counseling certificate, and California bars any fee until seven days after counseling. The appraisal fee is therefore the first money you spend. Federal HECM ruleCalifornia law
- The lender orders it; nobody picks the appraiserThe appraiser must be on FHA’s Appraiser Roster and hold a California credential. Neither you nor I choose the person, and nobody may tell the appraiser what number is needed. Federal HECM rule
- The visitUsually under an hour. The appraiser measures the home, photographs it inside and out, looks at the roof, foundation, attic and crawl space where they can be reached, and runs the heat, water and electricity, so the utilities must be on. Clear access to every room, the garage and any second unit.
- Comparable salesThe value comes from recent sales of similar homes nearby, adjusted for the differences: size, lot, condition, view, garage, pool, a second unit. In a tract neighborhood those sales are usually close and recent. For a custom home, a view lot or acreage the appraiser may have to reach farther away or further back, and must explain why.
- The report, and what the lender does with itYou get a copy: federal law requires the lender to give you every appraisal promptly, and no later than three business days before closing. The lender’s underwriter reviews it, and FHA’s own risk review may call for a second appraisal. Federal HECM rule
- How long it lastsAn FHA appraisal is good for 180 days from its effective date. If the loan will close later than that, an appraisal update can stretch it to one year from the original date. Federal HECM rule
What happens when the appraisal comes in below your estimate
The loan is figured on the appraised value or the 2026 FHA limit of $1,249,125, whichever is lower. On a purchase it is the lower of the price and the appraisal. When the number disappoints, here is what can and cannot happen.
| Step | When it is available | What it does |
|---|---|---|
| Correct a factual error | Always | A wrong bedroom count, living area, lot size or a missed permitted addition is sent back to the appraiser with the proof. |
| Reconsideration of value | When information that existed on the appraisal date was not considered | The lender’s underwriter sends the appraiser the missed sales or facts. Since March 19, 2025 the request comes from the underwriter; HUD withdrew the separate borrower-run process it had created in 2024. If the missing data was not your fault, the extra appraiser fee cannot be charged to you. Federal HECM rule |
| A second appraisal, lender’s choice | Only if the first is materially deficient and the appraiser will not fix it | Examples HUD gives: an unreported safety or structural defect, comparables that are outdated or not similar. The lender pays for it. A lender may not order one just to get a higher number. Federal HECM rule |
| A second appraisal, FHA’s choice | When FHA’s collateral risk review asks for one | Its cost can be financed in the loan, and the lower of the two values is used. Federal HECM rule |
| Take the smaller loan | Always | Every $10,000 of value moves the amount by roughly $4,000 at age 74 (see the example below). |
| Wait, or switch programs | Always | A new HECM appraisal is possible once the first one expires. A private jumbo lender orders its own appraisal under its own rules. Lender requirement |
What helps most is what you hand the appraiser at the door: a list of improvements with dates and permits, the solar purchase papers if you own the panels, and any recent sales on your street you know about, including private ones.
The quick version of this section is in Ask Ken: how the appraisal works and what if it comes in low, disputing a value and second appraisals.
Which property types qualify for a HECM
The federal rule is 24 CFR 206.45. A private program can be looser or stricter.
| Property | HECM | What decides it |
|---|---|---|
| Single-family house, townhome, planned development | Eligible | You live there as your principal residence. Federal HECM rule |
| Two to four units | Eligible | You must live in one of the units. Rent from the others can count as income with a lease and history. Federal HECM rule |
| Condominium | Eligible if the project is FHA-approved, is a site condominium, or the unit gets FHA Single-Unit Approval | I check HUD’s list before anyone pays for an appraisal. Single-unit approval has its own conditions and limits how many units in a project FHA will insure. Federal HECM rule |
| Manufactured home | Eligible if built on or after June 15, 1976, with its HUD label or a replacement certificate, on a permanent foundation on land you own, never moved from its first site | An engineer certifies the foundation. In California the home must also be converted to real property and taxed that way. A home on a rented space in a park does not qualify. Federal HECM ruleCalifornia law |
| A house with an accessory dwelling unit (ADU) | Eligible | FHA allows one ADU on a one-unit home. The appraiser decides whether it is a house with an ADU or really a two-unit property, and the ADU’s area is valued separately from the main home’s living area. Federal HECM rule |
| Mixed use (a shop or office in the building) | Limited | The residential use has to dominate and the business use cannot affect the home’s safety. I confirm the share with the lender before an appraisal is ordered. Federal HECM rule |
| Acreage, rural property | Eligible when it is a residence, not a farm business | There is no fixed acreage cap in FHA’s rules. Land that could be split off and sold separately (“excess land”) is left out of the value, and wells and septic systems are checked. Federal HECM rule |
| Home held in a living trust | Eligible | Revocable or irrevocable; the lender reviews the trust. See the power of attorney and conservatorship guide. Federal HECM rule |
| Leasehold (you own the home, not the land) | Only under a long lease that meets HUD’s test | Rare in California outside a few leased-land communities. Federal HECM rule |
| Co-op, vacant land, a home you do not live in, a mobile home on rented land | Not eligible | HUD’s rule covers a residence you own and occupy. Federal HECM rule |
Private jumbo and second-lien programs set their own property rules. Some accept condominium projects FHA will not, and some do not lend on manufactured homes at all. Ask Ken: what kinds of homes qualify, condominiums, manufactured homes, two to four units.
Homes with a homeowners association: approval, dues and assessments
Much of California’s housing is in a common interest development: a condominium, a townhome complex or a planned community with a homeowners association. For a reverse mortgage the association matters in six ways.
| Subject | The rule | What it means for you |
|---|---|---|
| Whether the home qualifies | A house or townhome in a planned development qualifies like any other single-family home. A condominium needs its project on FHA’s approved list, FHA Single-Unit Approval, or to be a site condominium. Federal HECM rule | I look the project up before an appraisal is ordered. |
| Dues when you apply | Association dues are a property charge, like property taxes and insurance. The lender looks back 24 months and expects no unpaid dues in that time. Federal HECM rule | Bring the association’s statement. Late dues are treated as late taxes are: see the financial assessment guide. |
| Dues in the income test | Monthly dues and any special assessment count among your housing costs when the lender works out what is left over each month. Federal HECM rule | High dues can be the difference between passing and needing a set-aside. |
| What a set-aside pays | A Life Expectancy Set-Aside holds money for property taxes and homeowner’s and flood insurance. It does not pay association dues. Federal HECM rule | The dues stay your bill for as long as you own the home. |
| After closing | Paying the dues is an obligation of the loan. Unpaid dues are a default, the same as unpaid property taxes or insurance. Federal HECM rule | A reverse mortgage ends the mortgage payment, not the association’s. |
| The association’s own remedies | An association can record a lien for unpaid assessments (Civil Code 5675). It may not foreclose on that lien until the unpaid assessments reach $1,800 or are more than 12 months late (Civil Code 5720). California law | The association is a separate creditor with its own rights. Tell me about any dispute with it before you apply. |
Private jumbo programs approve condominium projects under their own rules; some accept projects FHA does not. Ask Ken: a reverse mortgage on a condominium.
Required repairs, the 15% rule and the repair set-aside
FHA does not require a perfect house. It requires one that is safe, secure and sound. Worn carpet, an old kitchen and dated paint are not repair items. These usually are: a roof at the end of its life or leaking, peeling paint on a home built before 1978, missing stair rails, exposed wiring, broken windows, a heating system that does not work, signs of a failing septic system, and active leaks or rot.
| Estimated cost of the required repairs | When they are done | How it works |
|---|---|---|
| No more than 15% of the maximum claim amount (the appraised value, capped at $1,249,125) | After closing | The money sits in a repair set-aside inside the loan. A rider to the loan states the date work must begin and the date it must be finished. Federal HECM rule |
| More than 15% | Before closing | With your own funds or other financing; the loan cannot close first. Federal HECM rule |
| A major hazard to health or safety, at any cost | Before closing | No exception. Federal HECM rule |
- The contractor is paid from the set-aside after an inspection, and 10% is held back until the final inspection passes.
- You can be reimbursed for materials you buy, but not for your own labor.
- The lender may charge an administration fee of no more than the greater of $50 or 1.5% of the money advanced.
- If the work is not started or finished as the rider requires, the lender stops other payments from the loan until it is done. Repair payments and required advances continue.
- Money left in the set-aside after the work is finished was never borrowed, so it never accrued interest. On an adjustable-rate loan it returns to the funds you can draw.
- On a HECM for Purchase the seller finishes major repairs before closing.
Ask Ken has the short version: does my home have to be in perfect condition and what the appraiser looks for.
Solar, PACE liens, unpermitted work and flood zones
| Item | Rule | What I do about it |
|---|---|---|
| PACE or HERO assessment | A home that would stay subject to a PACE assessment is not eligible for a HECM. The payoff is a mandatory obligation paid at closing, and loan proceeds may be used for it (Mortgagee Letter 2017-18). Federal HECM rule | Order the payoff demand early; it comes from the program’s administrator, not the county. |
| Solar panels you own | Part of the home. A loan you took to buy them is a lien or a debt like any other. | Bring the purchase contract so the appraiser can count the system. |
| Leased solar or a power purchase agreement | The equipment belongs to the solar company and adds no value. The lender reads the lease, and a fixture filing the company recorded against the title has to be dealt with before closing. Lender requirement | Get the agreement and the company’s contact to me on day one. |
| Unpermitted additions and garage conversions | Not an automatic problem. An addition counts as living area only if you can reach it from inside the house and it has permanent heat; otherwise it is valued separately, sometimes at little or nothing. A health or safety defect must be fixed. Federal HECM rule | Tell me before the appraiser finds it. |
| Flood zone | The lender, not the appraiser, determines the flood zone. In a special flood hazard area flood insurance is required; where federal flood insurance is not available, or inside the Coastal Barrier Resources System, the home is not eligible. Federal HECM rule | I check the FEMA map with the address. |
| Federal tax lien | May stay only with a repayment agreement and at least three months of on-time payments; otherwise it is paid at closing. Delinquent federal debt makes a borrower ineligible until resolved. Federal HECM rule | The loan can often pay it off. |
Ask Ken: PACE and HERO loans and unpermitted work, extra structures and acreage.
How the rules differ for a HECM, a jumbo and a second-lien reverse mortgage
| Subject | FHA HECM | Private jumbo | Second-lien reverse |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who sets the rules | HUD: 24 CFR part 206 and Handbook 4000.1 Federal HECM rule | The lender Lender requirement | The lender Lender requirement |
| Appraiser | Must be on FHA’s roster | Lender’s panel; high values often need two appraisals | Lender’s panel |
| Value counted | Appraised value up to $1,249,125 | Full appraised value, up to the program’s maximum loan | Full value, behind your first mortgage |
| Condominiums | FHA project approval, site condo or single-unit approval | Lender’s own project review | Lender’s own project review |
| Manufactured homes | Yes, with the conditions above | Often no | Often no |
| Repairs | 15% rule and repair set-aside | Program by program | Program by program |
| Your copy of the appraisal | Required by federal law on a first-lien loan | Required, the same rule | The federal rule covers first liens; ask for your copy in writing |
Every reverse mortgage in California, HECM or private, also carries the state’s counseling, seven-day wait and disclosure rules. The full program comparison is in HECM vs. jumbo, rule by rule.
A low appraisal and a repair list, in dollars
Illustration, not a quote
A 74-year-old owner expects $900,000; the appraisal says $860,000 and lists two repairs
The appraiser finds three recent sales within half a mile and values the home at $860,000. The report lists a roof at the end of its life (bid: $19,000) and a missing stair rail and unstrapped water heater ($600).
| Figure | At the owner’s estimate | At the appraised value |
|---|---|---|
| Value the loan counts (maximum claim amount) | $900,000 | $860,000 |
| Principal limit at age 74 | $360,000 | $344,000 |
| Estimated closing costs, financed | $27,341 | $26,520 |
| Available after costs | $332,659 | $317,480 |
| 15% repair line | $135,000 | $129,000 |
| Required repairs | $19,600: under the line, so done after closing | |
| Left for other uses once repairs are set aside | $297,880 |
The lower value costs this owner $16,000 of borrowing power, about $4,000 for every $10,000 of value. The repairs, at $19,600, are far below the $129,000 line, so the loan closes first and the roofer is paid from the set-aside after inspection. The lender’s administration fee on those payments can be no more than $294. Had the roof bid been $140,000, the work would have had to be finished before closing.
HECM adjustable rate, “Most money” pricing on my rate sheet of November 19, 2026: starting rate 6.25%, expected rate 6.75%. Estimated APR 7.750% if that rate held: the calculator’s method, with the most HUD allows in the first 12 months drawn at closing and repaid in one payment after 12 years. Every rate I offer, and how its APR is figured. Closing costs are the calculator’s estimate. A hypothetical borrower; your figures depend on your age, the rates that day and the appraisal. Run your own numbers.
What is different about a California appraisal
- Safety items appraisers list here. California requires smoke alarms, carbon monoxide alarms in homes with gas appliances or an attached garage, and a braced water heater. They are cheap to fix before the visit. California law
- Unpermitted second units and garage conversions are common in California. A safe one does not have to come down, but it may be valued as a garage. Good practice
- Manufactured homes must be converted to real property: on an approved foundation system, recorded with the county and on the secured property tax roll. California law
- Condominium approvals lapse. Many California projects were FHA-approved once and are not today. Single-unit approval is the usual route. Federal HECM rule
- PACE assessments are collected on the county property tax bill, which is why they rank ahead of a mortgage and must be paid at closing. Federal HECM rule
- Fire insurance. HUD’s rule requires hazard insurance, and flood insurance in a flood zone; it does not require earthquake coverage. In high fire-risk areas the California FAIR Plan may be the only insurer, and its premium counts in the financial assessment. Federal HECM rule
- Proposition 13 and the appraisal are separate. The appraised value has nothing to do with your assessed value, and an appraisal for a loan does not trigger a reassessment. California law
- Appraisers are licensed by the Bureau of Real Estate Appraisers, and complaints about one go there. California law
Where the general rules change
- Bought within the last 12 months? Expect the appraiser and the lender to look closely at the price you paid.
- HECM for Purchase: the home must be finished (a certificate of occupancy for new construction), and the loan counts the lower of the price and the appraised value.
- Value above $1,249,125: the HECM stops counting there. A jumbo program counts the full value, with its own appraisal rules.
- Two appraisals that disagree: when FHA’s risk review required the second one, the lower value is used. You cannot choose.
- An expired appraisal means a new one, at a new fee, and possibly a different value.
- Repairs you cannot afford before closing (over the 15% line) usually end the HECM for now. A jumbo program, a repair loan first, or selling may be the better path.
- Wells and septic systems: the appraiser looks for signs of failure, and the lender may ask for a water test or an inspection.
- Leased land, life estates and co-owners are title questions, decided by the lender’s review of the documents, not by the appraiser. See co-owners and life estates.
What to do before the appraiser arrives
- Tell me what is unusual on the first callA second unit, work done without permits, solar, a PACE assessment, acreage, a condominium, a manufactured home, a recent purchase. None of these is a surprise I want the appraiser to deliver.
- Gather the papersPermits and final sign-offs, the solar contract, the PACE statement, the HOA’s contact, and for a manufactured home the recorded foundation document and the HUD label numbers.
- I check eligibility before you spend anythingCondominium approval, flood zone, title and liens are all checked before the appraisal is ordered.
- Counseling, then the seven-day wait, then the appraisalSee the process from first call to closing.
- Read your copy of the reportCheck the facts: bedrooms, baths, living area, lot size, the second unit, and whether the comparable sales are really comparable.
- Decide on repairs and valueGet bids for anything on the repair list, and if a fact is wrong or a sale was missed, send me the proof the same week.
The rules this guide is built on
Each was read on November 22, 2026. The regulation links go to the official text.
- 24 CFR 206.45: eligible properties: ownership, units, condominiums, flood insurance. Read November 22, 2026.
- 24 CFR 206.47: property standards and the 15% repair rule. Read November 22, 2026.
- 24 CFR 206.205: property charges, association dues among them, and what follows when they go unpaid.
- Civil Code 5675: an association’s lien for unpaid assessments.
- Civil Code 5720: when an association may foreclose: $1,800, or more than 12 months late.
- HUD model HECM repair rider: the dates, the 10% holdback, the administration fee and what happens when work is late.
- HUD Mortgagee Letter 2022-11: July 12, 2022: an appraisal is good for 180 days, and an update extends it to one year.
- HUD Mortgagee Letter 2018-06: September 28, 2018: the second appraisal FHA’s risk review can require, and that the lower value is used.
- HUD Mortgagee Letter 2025-08: March 19, 2025: when a second appraisal may be ordered, reconsideration of value, and the end of the 2024 borrower-run process.
- HUD Mortgagee Letter 2025-18: June 27, 2025: appraisal reporting requirements HUD withdrew.
- HUD Mortgagee Letter 2017-18: December 7, 2017: PACE assessments must be paid at closing.
- HUD Handbook 4000.1 glossary: HUD’s definitions of accessory dwelling unit, excess land and mixed use (last revised August 12, 2026).
- HUD HECM origination training, part one (April 10, 2024): flood zones, living trusts, federal tax debt.
- 12 CFR 1002.14: your right to a copy of every appraisal.
- HUD Handbook 4000.1: FHA’s appraiser and property requirements in full.
Appraisal and property questions, briefly
How long is a reverse mortgage appraisal good for?
Who chooses the appraiser on a reverse mortgage?
What is the 15% repair rule on a HECM?
Can I order a second appraisal if the first one is low?
Is earthquake insurance required for a reverse mortgage in California?
Something unusual about your home?
A second unit, solar, a condominium, acreage, work without permits: tell me before anyone orders an appraisal, and I will tell you how it is likely to be treated.
- The first call is free
- No application or documents needed for it
- I call you myself
- No obligation
Fifteen minutes. Real numbers. Then you decide.
Tell me the scenario and I’ll tell you honestly whether this is the right tool. If it isn’t, you’ll leave the call knowing why, and I’ll point you at whatever is.
(818) 674-7284Prefer email?
Send a couple of sentences about your situation and I’ll reply personally, usually the same business day.
Contact Ken Book a call